We read every UK employment tribunal decision mentioning ADHD. 298 are really about ADHD. Here is what actually decides these cases.
The ADHD Tribunal Files is the first complete analysis of every published UK employment tribunal decision mentioning ADHD: 537 decisions screened and 298 core ADHD cases, February 2017 to October 2026, read and coded by Collette Easton. Not summaries, not keyword counts. Judgments.
The finding that matters most: outcomes track manager behaviour, not claimant condition. Claimants won 18% of cases where the judgment records no management failures. Across the main failure patterns, they won 53% to 91%.
What changed since July, in seven slides.
298 core ADHD cases from 537 decisions screened. Scroll across to read them. Then take them: download one slide or all seven, copy the caption, and post them as they are.
298 UK employment tribunal cases about ADHD, read and coded. What managers do still predicts these cases better than anything about the employee, and employers who do it properly are winning with receipts. Full research: colletteeaston.com/research Research by Collette Easton #ADHD #HR #EmploymentLaw #Neurodiversity
Free to share, unedited, with credit to Collette Easton and a link to colletteeaston.com/research.
Why this research exists
In late 2025 I set up a Google alert for "ADHD + tribunal". I wanted to understand whether the cases could help me show clients that workplace behaviour is rarely as straightforward as it looks to colleagues. Then the alerts changed: bigger employers, faster frequency, and finally a headline: tribunal cases linked to neurodiversity had almost doubled in five years.
A hypothesis formed, built partly on questions I had spent years asking about my own career. Could ADHD symptoms be misread as poor behaviour? Does that misreading trigger shame and rejection sensitivity, and does the shame produce the withdrawal and outbursts that then get managed as performance problems, with no one, at any stage, asking why a character flaw is being processed as a capability issue? Does the cycle end in resignation or dismissal, and then repeat at the next job? And underneath the published cases, how many people never claimed at all, just packed up their shame and left quietly, taking their knowledge with them?
I knew this cycle from the inside. Early in my career I went through a tribunal process myself; the stress of it stays with me still, and I would not understand the wiring underneath my own working life for another two decades. So we went to the only place where the cycle is documented under oath: every published judgment.
This research is what we found.
How many ADHD tribunal cases are there really?
Fewer than the headlines say, growing faster than most employers think. We screened 537 published decisions that mention "ADHD", from February 2017 to October 2026. Only 298 are really about ADHD; in the rest, the keyword belongs to a family member, a colleague, a quoted guidance document, or a condition mentioned in passing. Public counts based on keyword searches overstate the litigated volume by nearly 2×.
The core cases are still growing steeply: 12 in 2020 to 75 in 2025, six-fold in five years. And 2026 has already passed 2025, with 79 cases to 9 October. Since 1 October 2026, most tribunal claims can be brought up to six months after the event, double the old limit. From 1 January 2027, unfair dismissal protection starts after six months’ service rather than two years, and the cap on compensation is removed. Disability discrimination claims, the bulk of this corpus, never needed any qualifying service.
2026 has already passed 2025.
to 9 Oct
What do these cases cost?
| Measure | Figure |
|---|---|
| Median award (40 core cases with stated awards) | £19,500 |
| Largest award (Wright-Turner v LB Hammersmith & Fulham) | £3,780,587 |
| Defence costs, borne win or lose | £8,500–£50,000+ |
| Claimant success rate at merits hearings | 39% |
Median from the 40 core cases with a stated award, October 2026. Discrimination awards are uncapped. Defence costs come on top, and are paid win or lose. Largest award and success rate are from the July 2026 analysis of 259 core cases.
Yes, you read the last line correctly: claimants lose most of these cases. Employers still pay to defend every one. The risk isn't losing. It's playing. And the tribunal record is the visible fraction: for every published judgment, our modelling suggests several hundred to a thousand ADHD-affected employees simply leave their jobs without ever claiming.
What are the Four Misreads?
The Four Misreads are the four ways managers document ADHD symptoms as character flaws: detail errors as carelessness, undone tasks as laziness, emotional reactions as aggression, and lateness as disrespect.
They are the engine of this corpus. Almost none of these cases involve slurs or deliberate discrimination. They involve a symptom, read as a character flaw, and then documented as one, at which point the write-up becomes the claimant's paper trail. The most litigated trait is not the one people guess: inattention and detail errors, read as carelessness, appear in 114 cases in the July 2026 analysis, ahead of lateness (23), emotional dysregulation (59) and task initiation read as laziness (63). Anxiety or depression appears alongside ADHD in 104 cases; in many, the ADHD surfaced only after years of being managed as a "stress problem".
What loses these cases for employers?
Six patterns, in order of how often judgments record them (July 2026 analysis, 259 core cases):
- Grievances mishandled (59 cases), the single most common failure
- Performance management without adjustments (54)
- No manager neurodiversity training evident (50), and where this appears, claimants won 70% of the time
- Adjustments agreed but delayed or never implemented (43)
- Rigid absence processes (41)
- Adjustments refused (39)
The pattern closest to a rule: where a PIP or dismissal followed an ADHD disclosure, claimants won 10 of 11 cases. The one exception was a dismissal for genuine misconduct, where the employer didn’t know about the ADHD beforehand. The starkest example is Ghiotto v Hawkwell House Hotel (2025): an employee disclosed self-identified, undiagnosed ADHD and was dismissed the next day, on the belief that no diagnosis meant no protection. Direct discrimination.
What saves employers?
The employers who won did unglamorous things: they documented adjustment decisions and their reasons at the time; they read occupational health reports and acted on them; they trialled adjustments even when imperfect; they paused formal processes when a disability entered the picture. In the judges' words:
"There was no evidence that the claimant's ADHD was considered before the decision to suspend, or that the OH report had been read."
Jackson v Kent County Council"The respondent failed to act on that first OH report and failed to make such adjustments as would have been reasonable."
Colfer v Secretary of State for JusticeThe October update put a number on it. In 14 of 15 new cases employers won, the tribunal credited specific good practice. The employers:
- Acted on OH advice quickly
- Provided assistive tech and training
- Reduced workload while support was set up
- Wrote adjustments down
The defensive playbook and the retention playbook turn out to be the same document. The paper trail that wins tribunals is a by-product of managing people well.
What surprised us in the October update?
Diagnosis doesn’t decide it
One person was found disabled with no diagnosis, and another with a diagnosis was found not disabled.
An impulsive resignation
It was treated as arising from ADHD, so refusing to let her take it back counted against the employer.
AI has reached the judgments
Two judges commented on claimants using AI to draft documents.
What should an employer do after an ADHD disclosure?
Pause before sanctioning. If any formal process is live when someone discloses, stop it moving until adjustments have been assessed and the plan revisited. We call this the Disclosure Pause, and it is the single highest-value habit in the corpus. Beyond that: treat OH advice as instructions rather than paperwork, record every adjustment decision including the declines, and brief managers on the Four Misreads before they write the word "careless" in a performance note.
The research tells you what loses. The Three Moments is what you hand a manager.
Everything on this page is free and stays free. What most employers ask for next is the same thing: the actual documents. Three working artefacts, built from the July 2026 analysis of 475 judgments, each line annotated with the case that put it there.
- The Disclosure First-Week ProtocolDay 0 script to Day 7 written close-out, because the duty starts at disclosure, not diagnosis.
- The Pre-Sanction Disability ChecklistEight questions before any PIP, disciplinary, probation decision or dismissal: the moment with the cleanest record of employer losses in the corpus.
- The Adjustments Decision LogOne record of every request, decision, reason and review date. "We did consider it" without a written trace reads as "we didn't".
Methodology, and what we got wrong
For the July 2026 edition, all 480 unique decisions were indexed from the GOV.UK employment tribunal database; 475 full judgments (99%) were retrieved and coded against a controlled schema covering claims, outcomes, awards, disability findings, ADHD traits described, and the management behaviours in each fact pattern. Five judgments could not be retrieved and are listed in the dataset.
Because coding at this scale uses AI-assisted extraction, we ran an independent verification pass against freshly fetched source judgments before publishing: 18 case-level claims checked, 10 confirmed exactly, 8 corrected for nuance, 0 unsupported. One early finding did not survive verification: our initial coding suggested nine process-after-disclosure losses; strict re-checking supports six of six, three with caveats, and we corrected every document that used the earlier figure. We publish that correction deliberately. If you quote this research, quote the verified numbers.
October 2026: refreshed the corpus to 9 October 2026: 537 decisions screened, 298 core ADHD cases. Figures marked “July 2026 analysis” come from the earlier edition and have not yet been re-run.
October 2026: we said claimants won 9 of 9 cases where a PIP or dismissal followed disclosure. It’s now 10 of 11. The exception was a dismissal for genuine misconduct, where the employer didn’t know about the ADHD beforehand.
October 2026: corrected the dates of two employment law changes. The six-month claim window started on 1 October 2026, not in 2025. Unfair dismissal is not becoming a day-one right: from 1 January 2027 the qualifying period falls from two years to six months.
Every case in the corpus is a public record; the full case list with GOV.UK links is available in the case index (CSV). Aggregate figures carry ordinary extraction-error risk and we invite corrections: collette@colletteeaston.com.
Frequently asked questions
Does an employee need a formal ADHD diagnosis to be protected?
No. The Equality Act protects anyone whose condition has a substantial, long-term effect on day-to-day activities. An employer was found to have directly discriminated for dismissing an employee with self-identified, undiagnosed ADHD (Ghiotto v Hawkwell House Hotel, 2025).
How often do employers win ADHD tribunal cases?
Most of the time: claimants succeeded in 39% of merits-decided core cases in the July 2026 analysis. But the win rate collapses where specific management failures appear, and defence costs of £8,500–£50,000 are unrecoverable even in victory.
Who conducted this research?
Collette Easton: a three-time founder-CEO, diagnosed with ADHD at 49, accredited coach. She designed the study and set the hypotheses; the reading and coding of the judgments was AI-assisted; the analysis, the published conclusions and the toolkit built from them are hers, and every published claim was independently verified against the source judgments.
Can I use these findings?
Yes, with attribution to "The ADHD Tribunal Files, Collette Easton, colletteeaston.com/research". The one thing we ask: use the verified numbers, exactly.
The patterns above are free, and always will be. The Three Moments is the version you can put in a manager's hands on Monday: the disclosure protocol, the pre-sanction checklist and the adjustments log, annotated with the cases behind every line. £295, one organisation licence, less than one claim.
This research is management education, not legal advice. Case characterisations are drawn from published judgments at gov.uk/employment-tribunal-decisions. © Loops Work Limited, 2026.
Running or want to attend an ADHD event? This calendar has every event in one place. You can also subscribe to it.
See ADHD Event Calendar →





